The KPMG Target Operating Model (TOM) is a detailed blueprint designed for organizations aiming to align their operations with strategic goals to drive efficiency, effectiveness, and competitive advantage. Here's an in-depth look at its framework:

1. Functional Process:

   • Core to the TOM is the delineation of the business's operational activities.

   • The focus is on process optimization, mapping out every activity within an organization to ensure they are as streamlined and efficient as possible.

   • This involves dissecting complex processes into more manageable sub-processes, identifying bottlenecks, and creating a process architecture that supports agility and continuous improvement.

2. People:

   • The model acknowledges the significance of human capital in the execution of processes.

   • It stresses the importance of clear role definitions, accountability, and reporting structures, aligning with strategic business objectives.

   • It further incorporates skill mapping, ensuring that each employee’s capabilities are aptly utilized and developed.

3. Service Delivery Model:

   • This element defines the 'what' and 'where' concerning service provision.

   • It involves decisions around insourcing versus outsourcing, centralization versus decentralization, and the use of shared service centers or centers of excellence.

   • The model specifies how the organizational capabilities will be distributed geographically, which processes will be kept in-house, which will be outsourced, and how service delivery can be optimized.

4. Technology:

   • Recognizing technology as a pivotal enabler, this component integrates the necessary digital tools, platforms, and infrastructures.

   • It focuses on the digital ecosystems that support process automation, information flow, and communication across the organization.

   • Considerations include cloud computing strategies, data analytics platforms, cybersecurity frameworks, and the adoption of emergent technologies like AI and IoT.

5. Performance Insights & Data:

   • The model emphasizes the strategic use of data and analytics to generate actionable insights.

   • It establishes KPIs and performance benchmarks tailored to the business objectives, thereby setting standards for success and facilitating a culture of data-driven decision-making.

   • This involves setting up data governance frameworks, data quality management, and reporting structures that provide timely and accurate information to stakeholders.

6. Governance:

   • Governance within TOM ensures that there is a clear structure for oversight, risk management, and compliance.

   • This comprises establishing robust policies and procedures, control mechanisms, and compliance frameworks that safeguard the organization against risks and mismanagement.

   • The model promotes transparency and accountability through the segregation of duties, audit trails, and policy enforcement.

The integrative components of KPMG's TOM are enriched by:

• Extensive Repository of Predefined Processes: Spanning across finance, HR, IT, and more, which serve as a reference point for process standardization and improvement.

• Organizational Structure Design: Clarifying job roles and interconnections to foster organizational coherence.

• Shared Services and Outsourcing Models: For cost-effective and specialized operational capabilities.

• Technological Foundations: Such as reference architectures, pre-configured integrations, and testing protocols to build a resilient and adaptable IT landscape.

• Performance Metrics Framework: Utilizing KPIs and benchmarking to continuously gauge and enhance performance.

• Risk Management and Control Systems: Instituting preventive and detective controls to address operational risks and ensure policy adherence.

Through its comprehensive structure, KPMG's TOM not only serves as a roadmap for achieving operational excellence but also facilitates transformational change, embedding a culture of continuous improvement, and strategic alignment across the business. This model is adaptable, allowing it to evolve alongside the organization to meet future challenges and leverage emerging opportunities.

________

Applying KPMG’s Target Operating Model (TOM) to Target’s case, particularly during the COVID-19 period where the retail giant transformed its stores into distribution centers to meet the surge in local customer demand, involves several key strategic shifts. Let’s dive into how each aspect of the TOM could be leveraged in this scenario:

1. Functional Process:

   • For Target, this would mean re-engineering store operations to function effectively as both retail spaces and distribution centers.

   • Processes such as inventory management, order fulfillment, and supply chain logistics would need to be optimized for efficiency.

   • Implementing systems for real-time inventory tracking would ensure that the increased demand is met without overburdening the supply chain.

2. People:

   • Employees would need to be cross-trained to handle both in-store customer service and online order processing.

   • The change would require a redefinition of job roles, including new responsibilities for store employees to manage online orders.

   • The HR function would need to recalibrate its approach to talent management, recruitment, and retention to support this new operational model.

3. Service Delivery Model:

   • Target’s shift to use stores as distribution centers aligns with creating a multi-channel service delivery model.

   • This would demand a careful analysis of the geographic spread of stores to optimize delivery routes and times.

   • Partnerships with local delivery services or investment in an in-house delivery fleet would become essential to this model.

4. Technology:

   • Leveraging technology for an omni-channel retail approach would be crucial.

   • The integration of an advanced warehouse management system (WMS) within stores to handle the increased complexity of serving as a distribution hub.

   • Enhanced online platforms and mobile applications would need to support the surge in e-commerce activity.

5. Performance Insights & Data:

   • Target would require robust data analytics to understand customer purchasing patterns and forecast demand more accurately.

   • KPIs might include delivery times, order accuracy, inventory turnover rates, and customer satisfaction scores.

   • Dashboards and reporting tools would need to be put in place for real-time performance tracking.

6. Governance:

   • Strong governance protocols would be needed to oversee the expanded risk profile of the stores-cum-distribution centers.

   • This would involve compliance with health and safety regulations, particularly under COVID-19 conditions.

   • Policies regarding inventory management, data protection, and employee safety would need to be rigorously defined and enforced.

Real World Application:

When integrating these components into Target’s real-world scenario during COVID-19, the financial and operational data would reflect significant changes:

• The surge in share price from $72 to $240 would be indicative of investor confidence in Target’s revised operating model.

• The tripled market cap suggests a dramatic increase in equity value, reflecting the organization’s successful pivot and the market’s positive response.

• Operational data would likely show an increase in online sales, a faster inventory turnover rate, and possibly higher operational costs in the short term, offset by long-term gains in market share and customer base.

Practical Implementation:

Target's sales increase could be attributed to several practices aligned with TOM principles:

• Inventory Localization: Tailoring inventory to local tastes and demands using data analytics, leading to better stock management and faster delivery.

• Store Layout Optimization: Redesigning store layouts to serve dual functions efficiently without disrupting in-store shoppers.

• Dynamic Staffing Models: Implementing flexible staffing that can adapt to the fluctuating needs of both in-person and online fulfillment processes.

• Technology Upgrades: Using predictive analytics for demand forecasting, and deploying AI for personalized customer experiences online.

Financial Performance:

• The financial data from the period would reveal insights into capital allocation, especially the investment in logistics, technology, and training.

• Operating margins would need to be analyzed to determine the cost-effectiveness of the new distribution model.

• Revenue per square foot would be an important KPI, as it would measure the productivity of retail space amidst the new dual-purpose operations.

By employing a detailed approach to the TOM, Target’s transformation during the pandemic not only capitalized on the shift in consumer behavior but also set the stage for long-term operational resilience and customer-centricity. This strategic realignment likely played a pivotal role in Target's remarkable financial performance during a period of global economic uncertainty.

________

The application of KPMG's Target Operating Model (TOM) to Amazon’s multifaceted and expansive operation would involve a complex interplay of strategic design, operational efficiency, and innovative practices. Here's an in-depth analysis of how TOM could be applied across Amazon’s various business segments:

1. Functional Process:

   • Amazon would streamline processes across its diverse operations, from online retail to cloud services (AWS) to its physical store presence with Whole Foods and distribution centers.

   • Optimization of cross-functional processes such as inventory management across different business lines, integrating logistics for Whole Foods with Amazon's existing distribution network, and ensuring AWS's capacity planning aligns with traffic demands would be crucial.

2. People:

   • The TOM would require Amazon to continue developing a skilled workforce that is versatile enough to adapt to different segments of its operation.

   • Employees in Amazon's distribution centers might need training in the latest logistics software, while AWS staff would need to stay abreast of cutting-edge cloud technologies.

   • Amazon would maintain an emphasis on innovation, customer service, and operational excellence across its workforce.

3. Service Delivery Model:

   • Amazon’s service delivery model is complex, encompassing e-commerce, cloud computing, and grocery retail.

   • TOM principles would dictate that each business segment maintains a high level of service while looking for synergies, like using Whole Foods locations as pick-up centers for online orders.

   • The acquisition of shopping centers and outlets and their conversion into distribution centers would serve as a strategic move to bring products closer to the consumer, reducing delivery times and costs.

4. Technology:

   • Technology is a cornerstone of Amazon's operations. TOM would suggest continuous investment in Amazon’s technological infrastructure to support scalability and innovation.

   • For AWS, maintaining robust, secure, and scalable data centers to support massive internet traffic, like that from Netflix, is essential.

   • In retail operations, technology to automate warehouses and integrate them into the Amazon logistics ecosystem would be key.

5. Performance Insights & Data:

   • Data analytics would be pivotal for Amazon to understand consumer behavior, optimize AWS server load, and manage logistics efficiently.

   • Real-time tracking of KPIs such as delivery times, server uptime, and customer satisfaction rates would be vital.

   • Financial performance would be closely monitored, linking operational data with financial results to ensure profitability across segments.

6. Governance:

   • Effective governance would oversee each segment of Amazon’s vast operations, ensuring compliance with laws and regulations, particularly in areas like data security for AWS.

   • Risk management strategies would be crucial, considering the breadth of Amazon’s services and the potential impact of operational risks.

Real World Financials and Data:

In applying TOM principles to Amazon's financial and operational data:

• Amazon's significant investment in its logistics network, including its own delivery fleet, would be seen as a strategic move to assert control over its entire supply chain.

• AWS’s financials would reveal substantial revenue, with high margins due to the scalable nature of cloud services. AWS's dominance, as exemplified by hosting services like Netflix, which represents a significant portion of internet traffic, underscores the importance of reliable and expansive cloud infrastructure.

• Amazon's e-commerce platform would showcase a tight integration with its logistics and distribution network, with data showing how the conversion of bankrupt shopping centers into distribution hubs has reduced delivery times and improved customer satisfaction.

Practices and Innovations:

Amazon's real-world practices that align with the TOM framework include:

• Last-Mile Delivery Optimization: Using its fleet to compete with carriers like UPS, enhancing control over the delivery experience.

• Synergistic Use of Physical Space: Repurposing acquired shopping centers into distribution centers demonstrates a strategic approach to resource utilization.

• Continuous Technological Innovation: From its advanced recommendation algorithms on the e-commerce platform to the AI and machine learning applications in AWS and logistics.

Conclusion:

Amazon’s strategic decisions during this period reflect a sophisticated application of the TOM principles. Through the integration of its retail, cloud, and logistics operations, the company has not only weathered the challenges presented by market dynamics but has also leveraged these opportunities to strengthen its market position and financial performance. The transformation of failed retail spaces into thriving logistical hubs is a testament to Amazon’s agility and its adherence to a well-thought-out operating model.

________

Applying KPMG's Target Operating Model (TOM) to Starbucks requires understanding the coffee giant’s global retail operations, product offerings, and brand licensing deals, such as the one with Nestlé. It also involves recognizing Starbucks' market position, including its valuation in comparison with tech giants like IBM. Here's an exploration of how the TOM framework could be strategically applied to Starbucks:

1. Functional Process:

   • Streamlining and standardizing the in-store operations across the global chain to ensure consistency in customer experience is crucial.

   • Optimizing the supply chain to manage the procurement of coffee beans and other ingredients efficiently, especially given Starbucks' commitment to ethical sourcing.

   • Implementing systems to improve order speed and accuracy, both in-store and through digital ordering platforms.

2. People:

   • The people aspect would focus on staff training to ensure that baristas can deliver the high-quality service and product consistency Starbucks is known for.

   • Developing leadership and growth pathways for employees to maintain a motivated and skilled workforce.

   • Cultivating a company culture that aligns with Starbucks' brand values of inclusion, sustainability, and social impact.

3. Service Delivery Model:

   • Continuously evaluating and evolving the service delivery to meet changing customer preferences, which could include expanding mobile order and pay options, drive-thru services, and delivery partnerships.

   • Enhancing the 'third-place' experience Starbucks strives to offer – a comfortable space between home and work where customers can relax and socialize.

4. Technology:

   • Leveraging technology for a personalized customer experience, from mobile apps that remember previous orders to AI that predicts customer preferences.

   • Using data analytics to optimize inventory management and forecast demand more accurately, reducing waste and improving availability.

5. Performance Insights & Data:

   • Establishing KPIs around sales growth, customer retention, and satisfaction to measure performance across various markets.

   • Analyzing financials to ensure that licensing deals, like the one with Nestlé, are profitable and align with the brand's premium positioning.

   • Monitoring market cap and investor sentiment as a measure of brand strength and strategic success, aiming to sustain or increase the $100 billion valuation.

6. Governance:

   • Implementing robust compliance frameworks to meet the regulatory standards of all the countries Starbucks operates in.

   • Ensuring ethical practices in sourcing and environmental stewardship, critical for Starbucks' brand and corporate social responsibility commitments.

Real World Financials and Data:

• Starbucks' partnership with Nestlé, worth over $7 billion, involved selling the rights to market Starbucks Consumer Packaged Goods and Foodservice products globally, outside of the company’s coffee shops. This deal can be analyzed from a TOM perspective to evaluate how it aligns with Starbucks' overall brand strategy and operational efficiencies.

• The company's market cap, hovering around $100 billion, indicates robust investor confidence and a strong competitive position. This financial measure compares favorably with other industry giants and underscores the importance of maintaining operational excellence and strategic growth initiatives.

• Real-world practices might include scrutinizing same-store sales data, international expansion strategies, and the performance of new product rollouts.

Practices and Innovations:

• Global Retail Strategy: Continually refining the store footprint, including opening and closing stores based on performance and market saturation.

• Licensing and Brand Extension: Managing the licensing agreement with Nestlé, ensuring it contributes positively to the bottom line and brand equity.

• Sustainability Initiatives: For instance, Starbucks' commitment to reducing its carbon footprint and waste can be part of its governance and operational practices, resonating with its market positioning and customer base.

By integrating TOM principles, Starbucks can aim to further strengthen its market position, improve operational efficiencies, and enhance its global brand appeal. These strategic efforts contribute to the company's valuation, putting it in the same league as technology firms like IBM, despite being in the consumer goods and retail sector. The comprehensive application of the TOM framework helps in fostering a resilient and sustainable business model that can adapt to market changes and evolving consumer preferences.

________

To help students consolidate their understanding of KPMG's Target Operating Model (TOM) into long-term memory, you can use the following questions as part of a study guide or a quiz:

1. Understanding the Framework:

   • What are the six core components of KPMG's TOM, and how do they contribute to organizational efficiency?

   • Can you explain how the functional process aspect of TOM impacts overall business operations?

2. Application of Concepts:

   • How does the 'People' element of the TOM ensure that a company has the right talent to meet its strategic objectives?

   • In what ways can technology under the TOM framework lead to improved service delivery and customer satisfaction?

3. Service Delivery Model:

   • What is the significance of a service delivery model in the TOM, and what are some examples of service delivery choices a business might make?

4. Performance Measurement:

   • How would you establish Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) in accordance with the TOM, and why are they important?

   • What role does data play in the performance insights & data component of the TOM?

5. Governance and Risk Management:

   • Describe the governance aspect of TOM. How does it help in risk management and compliance?

   • Why is governance particularly important in industries that are heavily regulated?

6. Real-World Application:

   • How might a company like Starbucks apply the TOM to optimize its global operations?

   • Consider Amazon's various business lines; how does TOM provide a structured approach to managing such a diverse company?

7. Evaluation and Analysis:

   • How can the application of TOM contribute to a company’s market capitalization and investor confidence?

   • What might be the long-term benefits of implementing TOM for a multinational corporation?

8. Integration of TOM Elements:

   • Can you provide an example of how the governance element of TOM would interact with the functional process within an organization?

   • How does the service delivery model influence the people component in TOM?

9. Change Management:

   • Discuss how TOM can be utilized as a tool for change management within an organization.

   • What challenges might a company face when implementing the TOM, and how could it overcome them?

10. Innovation and Adaptation:

    • How does TOM encourage innovation within an organization?

    • In what ways must TOM be adapted when dealing with digital transformation initiatives?

These questions are designed to prompt deep thinking and reflection on the various aspects of KPMG's Target Operating Model, encouraging students to not only recall information but also to understand and apply these concepts in various business contexts.